Best Pizza in Cheshire, CT
From NY-style slices to wood-fired pies — Milford delivers.
Cheshire's thriving downtown and surrounding neighborhoods have developed a solid pizza scene that reflects the town's growing food culture. Whether you're grabbing a slice before heading to Bartlem Park or stopping by after exploring the Quinnipiac Trail, local pizzerias serve everything from classic New Haven-style pies to contemporary wood-fired options that satisfy serious pizza enthusiasts. These establishments have become neighborhood gathering spots, drawing families from across central Connecticut who appreciate quality ingredients and authentic technique. For anyone living in or visiting this charming New England town, discovering the right pizza place has become part of the Cheshire experience.
Showing 8 top pizza places in Cheshire, CT
Few pizza in Cheshire have earned the consistent praise that Benvenuti Pizza co has — 4.9 stars across 222 reviews. Closed Tuesday. Check their website for hours and booking.
Ritual Pizza Co is early-stage in Cheshire but already earning 4.9-star reviews — one to watch. Closed Monday and Tuesday. Call ahead to confirm availability.
Rated 4.6 stars by 36 customers in Cheshire, Avanti Grille is worth a closer look. Closed Monday. Visit their site for pricing and appointments.
Fuoco Apizza has logged 747 reviews and held a 4.5-star rating, making it one of Cheshire's most established pizza. Closed Monday. Check their website for hours and booking.
721 customers in Cheshire have reviewed Cheshire Pizza & Ale — their 4.5-star consensus speaks for itself. Call ahead to confirm availability.
With 581 reviews and a 4.5-star rating, Rossini's Italian Restaurant and Pizza has become a reliable go-to for Cheshire residents. Closed Tuesday. Visit their site for pricing and appointments.
A 4.4-star rating across 3883 reviews makes Viron Rondo Osteria a well-established presence among Cheshire pizza. Check their website for hours and booking.
Il Gusto Italian carries a 4.4-star rating from 177 customers in Cheshire — a solid, established option. Call ahead to confirm availability.
Own a pizza place in Cheshire?
Get featured on CT Finest and put your restaurant in front of hungry locals searching right now.
Get Listed →