Best Pizza in New Haven, CT
From NY-style slices to wood-fired pies — Milford delivers.
New Haven's pizza reputation runs deep, rooted in the city's Italian heritage and the entrepreneurial spirit that thrives around Yale and beyond. From the brick ovens of Wooster Square to innovative spots dotting Chapel Street and the neighborhoods beyond, the pizza scene here reflects the same creative energy that defines this coastal college city. Whether you're craving a classic New Haven apizza with fresh ingredients or something more contemporary, these establishments have earned their place through consistency and genuine craft rather than hype. Local pizza makers understand that in a city this proud of its food traditions, quality and authenticity aren't negotiable.
Showing 8 top pizza places in New Haven, CT
New Haven customers have left 1998 reviews for ZENELI Pizzeria e Cucina Napoletana and averaged 4.8 stars — an exceptional track record. Closed Tuesday. Check their website for hours and booking.
781 customers in New Haven have reviewed Ernie's Pizzeria — their 4.7-star consensus speaks for itself. Closed Monday. Call ahead before visiting.
With 2604 reviews and a 4.6-star rating, Pizza at the Brick Oven has become a reliable go-to for New Haven residents. Visit their site for pricing and appointments.
Est Est Est Pizza & Restaurant has logged 1375 reviews and held a 4.6-star rating, making it one of New Haven's most established pizza. Check their website for hours and booking.
10705 customers in New Haven have reviewed Frank Pepe Pizzeria Napoletana — their 4.5-star consensus speaks for itself. Call ahead to confirm availability.
With 1041 reviews and a 4.5-star rating, Yorkside Pizza & Restaurant has become a reliable go-to for New Haven residents. Visit their site for pricing and appointments.
A 4.4-star rating across 1361 reviews makes Da Legna at Nolo a well-established presence among New Haven pizza. Closed Tuesday. Check their website for hours and booking.
A 4.4-star rated pizza in New Haven, Bobbi's Pizza has 95 customer reviews. Call ahead to confirm availability.
Own a pizza place in New Haven?
Get featured on CT Finest and put your restaurant in front of hungry locals searching right now.
Get Listed →