Best Pizza in West Haven, CT
From NY-style slices to wood-fired pies — Milford delivers.
West Haven's pizza scene reflects the casual, community-focused character of this Long Island Sound waterfront town, where locals grab a slice before heading to the beach or catching a game at the University of New Haven. Whether you're walking off the boardwalk with an appetite or looking for a reliable neighborhood spot, the city's pizzerias deliver the kind of straightforward, quality pies that keep families coming back year after year. From thin crust to New Haven-style apizza traditions, these establishments have earned their place in the everyday rhythm of life along our coastal stretch of New Haven County.
Showing 8 top pizza places in West Haven, CT
Zuppardi's Apizza has logged 2976 reviews and held a 4.7-star rating, making it one of West Haven's most established pizza. Check their website for hours and booking.
115 reviews and a steady 4.7-star average: Salty Tomato Pizza has earned its standing among West Haven pizza. Closed Monday. Call ahead to confirm availability.
332 reviews and a steady 4.6-star average: Mike's Apizza & Restaurant has earned its standing among West Haven pizza. Closed Monday and Tuesday. Visit their site for pricing and appointments.
West Haven Pizza and Deli has built a solid following in West Haven — 4.6 stars from 168 verified customers. Closed Monday. Check their website for hours and booking.
867 customers in West Haven have reviewed Casa Bianca Pizza West Haven — their 4.5-star consensus speaks for itself. Call ahead to confirm availability.
With 856 reviews and a 4.5-star rating, Lorenzo's Ristorante Italiano has become a reliable go-to for West Haven residents. Visit their site for pricing and appointments.
CRISPY PIZZA earns 4.5 stars from its customers in West Haven, based on 78 reviews. Check their website for hours and booking.
A 4.3-star rating across 342 reviews makes Tom & Pat's Pizza a well-established presence among West Haven pizza. Closed Wednesday. Call ahead to confirm availability.
Own a pizza place in West Haven?
Get featured on CT Finest and put your restaurant in front of hungry locals searching right now.
Get Listed →