Best Pizza in Middletown, CT
From NY-style slices to wood-fired pies — Milford delivers.
Middletown's Main Street pizza spots reflect the vibrant energy of this Connecticut River Valley gem, where Wesleyan students and locals alike fuel up on quality pies between classes and exploring the neighborhood's eclectic shops. Whether you're grabbing a quick slice after hiking Wadsworth Falls or settling in for dinner near campus, these pizzerias offer the kind of reliable, made-right food that keeps Middletown's dining scene honest. From traditional New Haven-style to creative contemporary takes, the pizza places here know their craft and take pride in feeding a community that appreciates good food.
Showing 7 top pizza places in Middletown, CT
With 123 reviews and a 4.9-star average, Apizza Heaven is building a reputation worth noticing in Middletown. Closed Tuesday. Check their website for hours and booking.
1773 customers in Middletown have reviewed Mondo — their 4.6-star consensus speaks for itself. Call ahead to confirm availability.
With 823 reviews and a 4.5-star rating, Krust Pizza & Bourbon Bar has become a reliable go-to for Middletown residents. Closed Monday and Sunday. Visit their site for pricing and appointments.
Illiano's Ristorante and Pizzeria has logged 761 reviews and held a 4.5-star rating, making it one of Middletown's most established pizza. Check their website for hours and booking.
With 137 reviews and a 4.4-star average, Gia's Pizza Restaurant #2 is a dependable pizza choice in Middletown. Closed Tuesday. Call ahead to confirm availability.
1097 customers have rated Sicily Coal Fired Pizza in Middletown, settling on a 4.3-star average. Visit their site for pricing and appointments.
435 customers have rated Vero Cucino in Middletown, settling on a 4.3-star average. Closed Monday. Check their website for hours and booking.
Own a pizza place in Middletown?
Get featured on CT Finest and put your restaurant in front of hungry locals searching right now.
Get Listed →